How to Make the Best Deviled Eggs

Note: COOK the STORY may receive a commission on purchases made through Amazon/affiliate links.

Learn how to make perfect deviled eggs that look amazing and are delicious too. This post is sponsored by Stonyfield, Le Creuset and KitchenIQ.

Learn how to make perfect deviled eggs that look amazing and are delicious too.

I had never made deviled eggs before this summer. I was having a book club meeting at my place and I was at the grocery store trying to decide what to make. I spotted the already cooked and peeled hard boiled eggs in the deli cooler and suddenly knew that I had to make deviled eggs.

Definitely buying the eggs already cooked helps a ton. It’s not so much the cooking of the eggs that is time-consuming. It’s all the peeling. Especially in those cases that happen sometimes where the peels just aren’t coming off right. It takes a long time and your eggs look all pebbled and weird when you’re done. So, especially if making a big batch, get the already cooked eggs. Huge time and stress saver. And see how nice they look:

Deviled Eggs

Since that book club night I’ve made deviled eggs again several times, perfecting my recipe. One thing that I tried and loved was to swap out the mayo for Greek yogurt. The filling ends up much lighter and less rich, while still being delicious. I used the Stonyfield Whole Milk Organic Greek Yogurt. By using the whole milk version, there’s still richness there, just not the overkill that you get with mayo.

The other ingredients I included are a bit of lemon juice, some mustard powder, salt and then a sprinkling of smoked paprika for garnish and bit of flavor. I’ve used regular paprika and tried a hot paprika once too. I really prefer the smoked. It gives a nice warm smoky flavor that is a final last touch to the delicious eggs. And why mustard powder instead of prepared mustard? I like a little bit of heat, which you don’t get from regular mustard. Also, because the Greek yogurt has some tang to it, as does the lemon juice, I didn’t want to add another tangy component. The powder was the perfect solution. Really, this recipe is so so good.

Deviled Eggs Ingredients

So those are the ingredients. What do you do with them?

How to Make the Best Deviled Eggs


Cut the eggs in half.

Deviled Eggs


Pop out the yolks and put them into a bowl.

Deviled Eggs


Add your other ingredients to the yolks (except for the paprika). Mash it up really really well, until totally smooth, using a fork.

Deviled Eggs


Transfer the yolk mixture to a piping bag or a large ziptop bag. If using the ziptop bag, cut one corner of the bag off. Start with a small hole. You can always make it bigger if needed but you can’t make it smaller. Get your eggs onto a serving platter. The one I use is from Le Creuset and is is made for serving deviled eggs. See it down there? It’s pretty amazing, right?

Deviled Eggs

Note that even if your yolk mixture is really smooth, there are still sometimes lumps. If your spout gets clogged with a lump, just use your fingers to smoosh it and squeeze it out.


Use your fingers to sprinkle the eggs with smoked paprika.

Deviled Eggs

Serve immediately or cover and refrigerate for up to 1 day.

There you have it. Perfect deviled eggs. The printable instructions with ingredient amounts are below.

Perfect Deviled Eggs



Best Deviled Eggs

  • Author: Christine Pittman
  • Prep Time: 15 minutes
  • Total Time: 15 minutes
  • Yield: 12 servings


  • 12 peeled hard boiled eggs
  • 1/2 cup Stonyfield Whole Milk Greek Yogurt
  • 1 tsp. lemon juice
  • 1 tsp. mustard powder
  • 1/2 tsp. salt
  • 1/8 tsp. smoked paprika


  1. Cut the eggs in half. Pop out the yolks and put them in a bowl. Arrange the halved egg whites on a serving platter.
  2. To the yolks add the yogurt, lemon juice, mustard powder and salt. Use a fork to mash it really well until very smooth. Transfer mixture to a piping bag or a large ziptop bag. Cut one corner off of the bag, if using. Make the hole small to start. You can always make it bigger if needed but you can’t make it smaller.
  3. Pipe the yolk mixture into the hollows of the egg whites. If a lump blocks the whole of your piping bag/plastic bag, use your fingers to smoosh it and squeeze it out.
  4. Get a pinch of smoked paprika between your fingers and sprinkled it over the eggs. Repeat until all the eggs have a little dusting.
  5. Serve immediately or cover and refrigerate for up to one day.
Disclosure: I’m a brand ambassador for Stonyfield which means that I am compensated to promote their products on my site and in social media. For this post, Le Creuset and KitchenIQ provided the serving dish, cutting board, a whisk and measuring spoons to be used in making the dish and photographed. All opinions are my own.

2 Responses to “How to Make the Best Deviled Eggs”

  1. Patricia — September 26, 2016 @ 7:09 pm (#)

    I tried these, and I’m very sorry but my mother’s version of deviled eggs is in my opinion much tastier. Perhaps it’s the curry powder in that recipe that makes the difference, or the actually fresh eggs which while more time consuming are less likely to be treated with preservatives. So Nope not ‘The Best Deviled Eggs’

    • Christine Pittman — September 27, 2016 @ 10:37 am (#)

      Patricia, You could definitely try adding curry powder. I always find it overpowering in deviled eggs but I know that many people love it. Sometimes traditional recipes stick for a good reason.

Leave a Comment

Fill your busy life with great food!

Sign up to get my quick recipes and useful tips by email and receive my slow cooker ecookbook as a free thank you gift.