Frozen Yogurt Pie Recipe

This is a delicious and easy frozen yogurt pie recipe. It’s a mixture of yogurt and fresh cherries frozen into a pie crust. Just mix, freeze, cut, and serve!

Today I'm sharing the ultimate easy frozen dessert. It's a frozen yogurt pie recipe.

Today I’m sharing the ultimate easy frozen dessert. It’s a frozen yogurt pie recipe.

Did you know that frozen yogurt is really just yogurt that’s been frozen? To make frozen yogurt, put it in a covered freezer-safe container in the freezer and then stir it every now and then until frozen.

And you can also make frozen treats by combining yogurt with other ingredients in different ways.

For instance, you can make super simple frozen yogurt sandwiches by glopping some yogurt onto a cookie, topping it with another cookie and then freezing it.

It’s such a healthy frozen snack for the kids (and for moms too!).

Or make today’s unique frozen yogurt pie recipe by mixing yogurt with cherries and putting it into a pie shell.

If you like no-bake desserts like this one, you should also check out my recipe for peanut butter cup ice cream pie.

Quick and Easy Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie from


Here’s how to make the frozen yogurt pie recipe.


Frozen Yogurt Pie Recipe

  • Author: Allie McDonald
  • Prep Time: 10
  • Total Time: 2 hours 10 minutes
  • Yield: 8


This is a delicious and easy frozen yogurt pie recipe. It’s a mixture of yogurt and fresh cherries frozen into a pie crust. Just mix, freeze, cut, and serve!


  • 19” homemade baked pie crust or a bought pie crust baked according to package directions
  • 1/2 lb fresh cherries, pitted, stems removed, and halved
  • 2 tbsp honey
  • 1/2 tsp cinnamon
  • 1 and 1/2 cups low-fat vanilla yogurt


  1. In a medium-sized bowl, combine half of the cherries with the honey, cinnamon, and yogurt. Glop the yogurt mixture into the baked pie shell.
  2. Place the remaining cherries on top of the yogurt in a non-overlapping layer (these cherries won’t sink into the mixture and so will stay vibrant and pretty on the top of the pie).
  3. Put the pie in the freezer until frozen solid, at least 2 hours. If not serving immediately, cover the pie tightly with plastic wrap and keep it in the freezer for up to 2 weeks.
  4. Remove the pie from the freezer and let it sit at room temperature for 5-10 minutes, just to let it soften slightly. Cut into 8 wedges and serve.


Frozen Treat Week

More Frozen Desserts:

This post is part of Frozen Treat Week where a group of us bloggers have gotten together to share our favorite frozen treat recipes with you. Here are the other recipes that the participating bloggers have shared today:

Mango Raspberry Pops from Katie’s Cucina

Mango Margarita Boozesicles from Nutmeg Nanny

Blood Orange Chocolate Popsicles from Rachel Cook’s

Cookies & Ice Cream Pie from Chocolate & Carrots

Pineapple Mint Popsicles from Sweet Remedy

3-Minute Easy Cherry Chocolate Sorbet from An Edible Mosaic

Chocolate Blueberry Crumble Pop from Cooking with Books

Bananas Foster Ice Cream from The Baker Chick

1 Ingredient Cherry Ice Cream from Foodie with Family

White Chocolate Buttermint Ice Cream from Eats Well With Others

Strawberry Cheesecake Popsicles from Damn Delicious

This post originally appeared in July, 2013 and was revised and republished in May, 2018.

Frozen Yogurt Pie Recipe

27 responses to “Frozen Yogurt Pie Recipe”

  1. Mary Gardner says:

    This looks so good. My daughter really loves cherries so I will make this one for her.

  2. […] Cherry Frozen Yogurt Pie from Cook The Story […]

  3. Catherine says:

    Hi Christine,
    Immediately after taking this out of the freezer, will it be rock hard? I’m not sure 5-10 minutes of leaving it in room temperature will be enough to soften it to an edible consistency. Thanks!

  4. […] Click here to enter to win one of two prize packs: 1) A Zoku Ice Pop Maker and Zoku Accessories; 2) … […]

  5. […] Frozen Dessert! Easy Cherry Frozen Yogurt Pie ( […]

  6. Jean says:

    Here’s a link the recipe for salted caramel ice cream!

  7. […] Cherry Frozen Yogurt Pie by Cook the Story […]

  8. […] Cook the Story – Coffee Smoothie with Fresh Cherries […]

  9. I’m a sucker for frozen pies. :D This cherry one looks fantastic!

  10. I’m so glad I found this recipe. I would have definitely broken down…dessert for breakfast with this one!

  11. Shaina says:

    I looooove cherries! This sounds great, and with cherries being in season right now it’s the perfect dessert to make!

  12. Samantha says:

    I just ate birthday cake for breakfast… I don’t think it was my mom’s fault… even though I would love to blame her instead. :) Love the cherry aspect in this pie. Cherry season is the best season!

  13. I am a total cherry junkie this time of year…this beautiful pie would be a HUGE hit in my house!!

  14. Katie says:

    Ha ha I love his thinking! I say let him eat pie for breakfast once! It will be special… after all it is frozen yogurt ;) Love this recipe. Must make me one soon! Thanks for participating in Frozen Treat Week!

  15. Oh YUM! Cherry and yogurt are two of my favourite things. I think my boys would really dig this…

  16. I love that your son is so obsessed with this pie- I would be too! It looks so light and refreshing!

  17. […] Cook the Story – Easy Cherry Frozen Yogurt Pie […]

  18. Marnely Rodriguez-Murray says:

    Thanks for the tips on freezing yogurt, good to know!

  19. […] today!  Rachel Cooks Chocolate & Carrots Sweet Remedy An Edible Mosaic Katie’s Cucina Cook the Story The Baker Chick Nutmeg Nanny Foodie With Family Eats Well With Others Disclaimer: Winner will be […]

  20. […] Cook the Story – Easy Cherry Frozen Yogurt Pie […]

  21. […] Brandy – Nutmeg Nanny Rachel – Rachel Cooks Caroline – Chocolate & Carrots Marnely – Cooking with Books Katie – Katie’s Cucina Joanne – Eats Well With Others Rebecca – Foodie with Family Faith – An Edible Mosaic Sam – Sweet Remedy Christina- Cook The Story […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating

Fill your busy life with great food!

Sign up to get my quick recipes and useful tips by email and receive my air fryer ecookbook as a free thank you gift.